How not to write in defense of threatened tortoises

Authors

  • Y.L. Werner

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.11609/JoTT.o2251.471-3

Abstract

Prudent use of the limited conservation resources rests on solid taxonomy data. This is a critical review of a taxonomy paper aimed at conservation but in itself not fully reliable (“Genetic evidence for premature taxonomic inflation in Middle Eastern tortoisesâ€, Parham et al., 2006, Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci. 57: 955-964). Its authors consider that unjustified naming of species is detrimental to conservation. This reviewer considers the paper flawed in (a) selection and reportage of voucher specimens, partly erroneous or inaccurate; (b) methods; (c) scientific reasoning and conclusions; and (d) clarity of argumentation. Hence even if the results are supported by the more solid results of others, the paper in itself is considered not to be sufficiently reliable for systematics or conservation.

Author Biography

Y.L. Werner

Yehudah L. Werner has participated in founding the Society for the Protection of Nature in Israel; taught, in various capacities, vertebrate zoology and herpetology at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem during 1953-1999; and edited the Israel Journal of Zoology during 1973-1989. As Professor Emeritus he continues to research.

Downloads

Published

26-09-2009

Issue

Vol 1, No 9 (2009)

Section

Communications

License

Authors own the copyright to the articles published in JoTT.  This is indicated explicitly in each publication. The authors grant permission to the publisher Wildlife Information Liaison Development (WILD) Society to publish the article in the Journal of Threatened Taxa. The authors recognize WILD as the original publisher, and to sell hard copies of the Journal and article to any buyer. JoTT is registered under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY), which allows authors to retain copyright ownership.  Under this license the authors allow anyone to download, cite, use the data, modify, reprint, copy and distribute provided the authors and source of publication are credited through appropriate citations (e.g., Son et al. (2016). Bats (Mammalia: Chiroptera) of the southeastern Truong Son Mountains, Quang Ngai Province, Vietnam. Journal of Threatened Taxa 8(7): 8953–8969. https://doi.org/10.11609/jott.2785.8.7.8953-8969). Users of the data do not require specific permission from the authors or the publisher.