Journal of
Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 September 2018 | 10(10):
12317–12327
Status of raptors in the Moyar River Valley, Western
Ghats, India
N.R. Anoop 1,
S. Babu 2, S. Bharathidasan
3 & R. Nagarajan
4
1,4 Department of Zoology and Wildlife
Biology, A.V.C. College (Autonomous), Mannampandal, Mayiladuthurai, Tamil Nadu 609305, India
1 Current address: Ashoka
Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment (ATREE), Royal Enclave, Srirampura, Jakkur Post, Bengaluru,
Karnataka 560064, India
2 Sálim Ali Centre for Ornithology and Natural History,
Anaikatty (PO), Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu 641108, India
3 Arulagam, Ellappalayam
(PO), Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu 641697, India
4 Centre for Research in Animal Behaviour
(CRAB), School of Psychology, Washington Singer Laboratories, University of
Exeter, Perry Road, Exeter, EX4 4QG, UK
1 anoop.shola@gmail.com (corresponding
author), 2 sanbabs@gmail.com, 3 arulagamindia@gmail.com, 4 R.Nagarajan@exeter.ac.uk
doi: https://doi.org/10.11609/jott.3054.10.10.12317-12327
| ZooBank:
urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:3D599DB8-8B35-4F0C-ADF5-CD7BA486DBE4
Editor: V. Gokula, National College, Tiruchirappalli, India. Date of publication: 26 September
2018 (online & print)
Manuscript details: Ms # 3054 |
Received 12 October 2017 | Final received 22 August 2018 | Finally accepted 01
September 2018
Citation: Anoop, N.R., S. Babu,
S. Bharathidasan & R. Nagarajan
(2018). Status of raptors in the Moyar
River Valley, Western Ghats, India. Journal of Threatened Taxa 10(10): 12317–12327; https://doi.org/10.11609/jott.3054.10.10.12317-12327
Copyright: © Anoop et al. 2018. Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International License. JoTT allows
unrestricted use of this article in any medium, reproduction and distribution
by providing adequate credit to the authors and the source of publication.
Funding: ATREE-CEPF.
Competing interests: The authors declare no competing interests.
Author Details: N.R. Anoop is a PhD student with Ashoka Trust for
Research in Ecology and the Environment (ATREE). His research focuses on the
ecology and behaviour of Asian Elephants in human dominated landscapes. Dr. S. Babu is Senior Scientist at Sálim
Ali Centre for Ornithology and Natural History (SACON), Tamil Nadu. His
research focuses on ornithology, landscape ecology, and Remote Sensing &
GIS. Mr. S. Bharathidasan has been
actively working for last 26 years in the areas of biodiversity and landscape
conservation, and nursery techniques. He is selected for
Bio-diversity Award for his contribution on wildlife conservation and
environmental writings in 2015 by Auroville
Foundation. He received one of the 15 Biodiversity Hotspot Hero award
for his contribution on Vulture conservation by Critical Ecosystem Partnership
Fund (CEPF) in 2016. He is one of the well-known environmental writers in Tamil
language. Dr. R. Nagarajan
is Principal in A.V.C. College (Autonomous) & Head, PG and Research
Department of Zoology and Wildlife Biology, conducting research in behavioural
ecology of wildlife pertaining to foraging and nesting. His research theme
includes factors influencing population of wildlife, nest-selection and life-history strategies of birds, role of Barn-Owl in rodent
pest control.
Author Contribuion: RN
and NRA conceived and designed the work. NRA, NR and SB conducted field surveys
and data collection. NRA led the writing of the manuscript with inputs from RN
and SB. All the authors equally contributed in refining the manuscript drafts
and approved the final version.
Acknowledgements: This research was part of the Masters dissertation for
the Post-graduate program in Wildlife Biology, A.V.C. College
(Autonomous). We are extremely grateful
to all faculty members of Department of Zoology and Wildlife Biology, A.V.C.
College (Autonomous), for their continuous support. We extend our sincere thanks to the
Management and Principal of A.V.C. College (Autonomous) for necessary support
to this study. We are grateful to Tamil
Nadu Forest Department for granting the permission to conduct the study. Our special gratitude goes to ATREE-CEPF for
financing support. We thank Mr. Nirav Bhatt for his kind help
in identifying several raptors. We
acknowledge Mr. Venkitachalam
for his valuable suggestions and constant encouragement throughout the study. We are indebted to Mr.
D. Boominathan, World Wildlife Fund (WWF-India) for
logistic support. We thank Mrs. Jyoti Nair and Mrs. Roshni Kutty,
ATREE for their valuable suggestions to improve the manuscript. We thank Mr. C. Sashikumar, Mr. P.A. Vinayan, Mr. Mohan and Mr. Chandrashekar for the
valuable discussions. We acknowledge Mr. Mahesh, Mr. Basuvan, Mr. Sakthivel
and Mrs. Revathi for their
help during field work.
Abstract: This study examined the species composition
and nest-tree characteristics of diurnal raptors in the tropical forests of Moyar Valley, Western Ghats between December 2012 and March
2013. We recorded 28 species of raptors
including three species of vultures. Accipitridae was the dominant family comprising of 25
species followed by two from Falconidae and the
monotypic Pandionidae. Among them, eight species fall under various
threatened category: three Critically Endangered, one
Endangered, two Vulnerable and two Near Threatened. The Critically Endangered Gyps bengalensis was frequently recorded during the survey
(175 sightings) followed by Milvus migrans (39 sightings) and Haliastur
indus (27
sightings). We located 53 active nests
of four species of raptors, viz., Gyps bengalensis
(42 nests), Nisaetus cirrhatus (4 nests), Haliastur
indus (4 nests), and Milvus migrans (3
nests). A notable difference in the
nest-tree characteristics among the sympatric raptors was observed. These results would be important to identify priority
areas for developing future conservation and management programs for the
long-term conservation of raptorial birds in the Western Ghats.
Keywords: Birds of prey, distribution, nest-tree
characteristics, Moyar Valley, Western Ghats.
INTRODUCTION
Raptors generally occupy the apex of terrestrial and
aquatic food webs, and thus play key roles in balancing ecosystems (Paine 1966;
Thiollay 1989; Anderson 2001; Thiollay
2006) by maintaining community structures of prey species (Keith et al. 1998;
Ferguson et al. 2005; Roth & Weber 2008).
Raptors typically have low population density and require large home
ranges, and they serve as good indicators of ecosystem quality (Newton 1979; Thiollay 1992; Redpath & Thirgood 1999) for conservation and management efforts
(Sergio et al. 2006). Raptor populations
are reportedly declining throughout the world owing to their high vulnerability
to environmental contaminants, habitat destruction, direct persecution and
diminishing prey availability (Crocker-Bedford 1990).
Raptor distributions are influenced by a variety of
factors, including landscape heterogeneity, interspecific competition,
predation and the availability of nest-sites and food resources (Thiollay 1989; Anderson 2001; Pearlstine 2006). Two-thirds of raptor species occur fully or
partially in tropical regions (Bildstein et al. 1998;
Ferguson et al. 2005), and India supports 69 raptor species together with
several subspecies and races (Naoroji 2006). Information on raptors and their habitat
associations are crucial for their conservation and management, but data on the
distribution and populations of most Indian raptors are lacking due to
difficulties in identification, low population densities and forest dwelling
habits (Thiollay 1994; van Balen
1998; Naoroji 2006).
The Western Ghats biodiversity region (Myers et al. 2000) has lost
nearly 50% of its forest cover since the early 1900s, and this trend is
continuing with increased fragmentation and encroachment (Nair 1991; Jha et al. 2000) by agriculture, plantations, hydroelectric
projects, logging, developmental activities, fire, grazing and
over-exploitation of forest produce (Nair
1991; Jha
et al. 2000; WGEEP 2011). In spite of
this high anthropogenic pressure, remnant forest patches in the Ghats remain
important habitats for diverse species of resident and migratory raptors (Naoroji 2006; Sashikumar et al.
2011). Except for a coarse-grained population
survey, no information is available for raptors of the Western Ghats. The Nilgiris
represent a unique landscape within the Western Ghats owing to their
topographical, climatic and habitat features, and the region is an important
wintering area for several migrant raptors (Primrose 1904; Gokula
& Vijayan 1996; Thirumurthi
1999; Naoroji 2006; Zarri
et al. 2008). Data on population status
and ecological requirements of raptorial birds in the Nilgiris
is poorly documented. In this context,
we examined the distribution and nest-tree characteristics of raptors in Moyar Valley. The
study results will provide baseline information for future conservation and
management plans for raptorial birds in Moyar Valley.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study area
The study was carried out in Moyar
River valley and adjacent Sigur Plateau (11.701280N–76.587060E
and 11.472440N–77.1476080E) in the Nilgiri
Biosphere Reserve, which links the Western and Eastern Ghats (Venkitachalam & Senthilnathan
2016). It is a wide south-east facing valley located
at the junction of four plateaus: the Sigur in
the northwest, the Nilgiri in the west, the
Mysore in the north and the Thalamalai Plateau in the
northeast. The valley is within the
borders of the Satyamangalam Tiger Reserve and the Nilgiris north forest division in Tamil Nadu, and Bandipur Tiger Reserve in Karnataka State. A deep gorge, the Moyar
gorge or ditch, in the northern boundary of the Nilgiri
District separates the Sigur and Mysore plateaus.
The terrain is hilly and the altitude of the study
area ranges from 300–950 m; the main ridge of the Nilgiri
Plateau is above 2,000m. The study area
receives rain from both the northeast and southwest monsoons, with more rain
coming during the former from September to December. The entire valley receives water from several
perennial and seasonal rivers, and it forms an important drainage basin of the Moyar River, a tributary of the river Cauvery. The Moyar meets the
Bhavani River in the east of the Nilgiri
Plateau. The major vegetation types of
the valley are tropical dry deciduous, southern tropical thorn forest, and
tropical moist deciduous forest includes riparian forests along the streams
interspersed with cultivated areas and reservoirs (Champion & Seth 1968; Prabhakar & Pascal 1994). Semi-evergreen and
evergreen forests skirt along the eastern slope of the Nilgiri
Plateau. At a comprehensive
level, the thorn forest and dry deciduous are the general vegetation in the
valley.
Methods
Population survey
Study was carried out between December 2012 and March
2013. To survey the raptors we placed 16
vantage points in the valley (Fig. 1).
The points for the survey were selected in elevated places or locations
with maximum visibility to detect the soaring raptors (Thiollay
1989; Nijman 2004; Eduardo et al. 2007) but no effort
was made to sample canopy dwelling species.
The survey locations were established in all major habitats of the study
area. The surveys were carried out from
09:00hr to 17:00hr and all the raptors were identified and counted within the
identifiable radius (ca. 700m) from the sampling locations (Eduardo et al.
2007; Kurup 2011).
Altogether, we carried out 288 hours of observations across five
different habitats, viz. 108 hours in open dry thorn forest (6 locations), 36
hours in mountain cliffs (2 locations), 54 hours in the reservoir (3
locations), 36 hours in the riparian forest (2 locations) and 54 hours in human
habitations (3 locations). The raptors
were observed by using Olympus (10×50) binocular and photographs were taken for
the identification of the difficult species (Sony HX 200V Prosumer
Camera, 30x optical zoom). Standard
field guides were used for the identification based on the plumage, shape, and
size of the raptors (Grimmett et al. 2011;
Ferguson-Lees & Christie 2005; Naoroji
2006). Taxonomy follows BirdLife International (2017).
Nest survey and nest-tree characters
The nests of different raptors were located through
intensive ground surveys by exploring all probable trees suitable for
nesting. The secondary information from
forest officials, field biologists, and settlers of the forest hamlets were
also collected. Nest locations were
geocoded with a global positioning system (Garmin eTrex
10) and the same was plotted on a forest boundary map using Q-GIS. The characteristic features of nesting trees
were measured to understand the habitat signature of nesting trees opted by the
raptors (Table 1).
RESULTS
We recorded 28 species of diurnal raptors, including
seven migrants (Images 1–25). Family Accipitridae was dominant,
contributing 25 species, followed by family Falconidae
(2 species) and the monotypic family Pandionidae
(Table 2). Of the 28 species recorded,
eight have high global conservation significance: three Critically
Endangered (White-rumped Vulture Gyps bengalensis, Red-headed Vulture Sarcogyps
calvus, and Indian Vulture Gyps indicus), one Endangered (Steppe
Eagle Aquila nipalensis), two
Vulnerable (Indian Spotted Eagle Clanga hastata and Greater Spotted Eagle Clanga
clanga), and two Near-Threatened (Grey-headed
Fish-Eagle Icthyophaga ichthyaetus,
Lesser Fish Eagle Icthyophaga humilis). The
White-rumped Vulture (42.2% of total sightings),
Black kite Milvus migrans
(9.4% of total sightings) and Brahminy Kite Haliastur indus
(6.5% of total sightings) were detected commonly during sampling. Species such as Grey-headed Fish-Eagle,
Western Marsh-Harrier Circus aeruginosus, Eurasian
Sparrow Hawk Accipiter nisus, Crested Goshawk Accipiter trivirgatus, Steppe Eagle
and Indian Spotted Eagle were encountered once during the study
whereas Rufous-bellied Eagle Lophotriorchis
kienerii, and Tawny Eagle Aquila rapax were recorded twice.
Among three species of vultures recorded, White-rumped Vulture had the maximum number of sightings (n=175)
followed by Red-headed Vulture (n=8) and Indian Vulture (n=6). All the vulture sightings were recorded in
the middle and lower ranges of the valley that has extensive open habitat. Maximum of 172 White-rumped
Vulture, four Red-headed Vulture and three Indian Vulture were observed in a
flock near Moyar Village. The vultures were observed feeding on
different animal carcasses, viz., four Elephants Elephas
maximus, four Chitals Axis
axis, three Gaurs Bos
gaurus, one Sambar Deer
Rusa unicolor, and four livestock
carcasses.
Nest-trees
We located 53 active nests of four sympatric raptors,
namely: White-rumped Vulture (42), Crested Hawk-Eagle
(4), Brahminy Kite (4), and Black Kite (3). Of these, nests of White-rumped
Vulture and Crested Hawk-Eagle were exclusively recorded on live trees of Terminalia arjuna
along the riparian forests of the valley.
The nests of White-rumped Vulture were
recorded from two different colonies such as Syriur
(14 nests) and Jagalikadavu-Chemmanatham (28 nests)
in Sigur Plateau.
Both Black Kite and Brahminy Kite nested on
smaller trees and all nests were recorded close to human habitation. Brahminy Kite
nested on live trees of Cocos nucifera and Albizia
spp. and nests of Black Kite were recorded on Ficus
religiosa and Albizia
spp. We also observed breeding
activities such as courtship display, mounting and collection of nesting
materials by Oriental Honey-buzzard.
Nest-tree characteristics
Among the observed nests, White-rumped
Vulture selected the tallest trees (42.21 (±6.827m) with a higher gbh 1.92 (±0.39m) for nesting than other raptors (Table
3). The nests were placed at a mean
height of 37.45 (±7.969m). Crested
Hawk-Eagle preferred comparatively shorter trees for nesting 29 (±8.8m) with a
smaller gbh 1.23 (±0.47m) and their nests were placed
at a mean height of 22m from the ground.
All their nests were supported by three branches. Brahminy Kite and
Black Kite preferred small trees with thin branches for carrying their
nests. They preferred shortest trees
with a small gbh when compared with other species.
Almost the same trend was seen in other characteristics features (Table 3).
DISCUSSION
The raptors of the Western Ghats biogeographic zone
have not been extensively studied (Naoroji
2006). Within the short span of this
study we recorded 28 species of diurnal raptors, including eight globally
threatened species: three Critically Endangered, one
Endangered, two Vulnerable and two Near Threatened. Of the raptors observed in this study, three
species were common, and five were fairly common with White-rumped
Vulture outnumbering all others.
Comparison with other published literature from the Western Ghats region
of Tamil Nadu reveals a high richness of raptors in the Moyar
Valley (Vijayan et al. 1992; Gokula
& Vijayan 1996; Johnsingh
2001; Swami 2006; Bundell 2010; Ramesh et al. 2012;
Ali et al. 2013; Babu & Bhupathy
2013). This could be attributed to
habitat heterogeneity, resource availability and the geomorphological features
of the valley.
Within the Nilgiris
landscape, White-rumped Vultures breed in Wayanad Wildlife Sanctuary (Kurup
2011) and the Moyar Valley, which holds a large
number of nests along the tributaries of the Moyar
such as the Syriur and Jagalikadavu
in the Sigur Plateau.
Secondary data from longtime settlers in the
valley revealed that White-rumped Vultures formerly
bred in colonies at Arakadavupallam, Masikoil, Mangalapatty and Thotikadavu. Red-headed Vulture also used to breed near Anakkal Mariamman Koil of Nilgiri North Forest
Division (Arulagam 2015). A recent study by Venkitachalam
& Senthilnathan (2015) recorded four nesting
sites of Indian Vulture from the valley.
Of two species of near-threatened raptors recorded
during the study, the Lesser Fish Eagle is uncommon along the Moyar River but seldom seen along its tributaries. Ten observations of this species were made
during vantage point count, and we had more than 30 sightings while searching
for raptor nests along the Moyar River. The Moyar River
supports a good concentration of fish fauna (Bhaskar
& Karthik 2015) and hence ensures ample food
resources for fishing eagles. We
recorded the juvenile of this species twice near Thengumarahada
Village, and we presume they may be breeding in the Moyar
Valley. We have also recorded this
species from adjacent protected areas such as the Tholpetty
Range and Bathery Range of Wayanad
Wildlife Sanctuary, along Nagarahole River in Nagarahole Tiger Reserve, along Moyar
River in Mudumalai Tiger Reserve and Nugu River in Bandipur Tiger
Reserve. Little is known about the
status of this species from southern India, but recently it was found breeding
in Eastern Ghats of Karnataka and Western Ghats region in Kerala (Ramarao 2011; Sashikumar
2011). Grey-headed Fish-Eagle was
sighted once in Thengumarahada Village on 9 December
2012. Earlier studies reported this
species from Tamil Nadu region of Nilgiri Landscape
such as from Mudumalai Tiger Reserve (Gokula & Vijayan 1996) and
Upper Nilgiris (Thirumurthy
& Balaji 1999).
We spotted this species once along Nugu River
in Bandipur Tiger Reserve. A Western Marsh-Harrier was observed in the
grassy meadow of Bhavanisagar Reservoir on 7 December
2012. We also observed one female
harrier near Ebanadu Village almost similar to Pallid
Harrier, but we have labeled it as unidentified
because of the confusion in identification with females of other harriers.
Of the two Vulnerable species
recorded, Indian Spotted Eagle is an uncommon raptor that occurs at very low
density across its distribution range and has been seldom recorded from the
Western Ghats (Naoroji 2006; Birdlife International
2012). Previously, it was reported from
Upper Nilgiris (Primrose 1904) and Mudumalai Tiger Reserve (Naoroji
2006), however, subsequent studies have not reported the species from Nilgiri landscape (Zarri et al.
2008; Thirumurthy & Balaji
2009). We recorded and photographed a
single individual at Maravakandi dam near Masinagudi on 28 January 2013 at an altitude of 924m. It was mobbed by an Osprey
during the observation. Greater Spotted
Eagle has been recorded from 24 different sites of Tamil Nadu and Puducherry (Santhakumar et al.
2016) and frequently seen in the wetlands of Northern Kerala and also along
Cauvery River basin of Karnataka (Naoroji 2006). This species was photographed four times
around Bhavanisagar Reservoir. This reservoir supports a large concentration
of wetland birds (Bharathidasan un-published data),
which may ensure ample food source for this raptor. We observed and photographed the Steppe
Eagle once near the Bhavanisagar
Reservoir. This is a common Aquila Eagle
in the northern Indian plains but rare in southern India (Sashikumar 2004; Naoroji 2006).
Tawny Eagle is a dry zone species found in the
cultivated plains and plateau of Tamil Nadu (Naoroji
2006), and it was reported from Mudumalai Tiger
Reserve and upper Nilgiris (Gokula
& Vijayan 1996; Thirumurthi
& Balaji 1999).
We recorded this species twice near Allimoyar
Village on 25 December 2014 and at a waste dump in Masinagudi
on 7 March 2013. The Brahminy Kite and Black Kite were sighted more often in and
around towns and associated waste dumps.
According to Naoroji (2006), these are common
raptors in many parts of India and they are frequently found in human-dominated
and disturbed habitats due to their high tolerance to human disturbance and
scavenging trophic niche.
An earlier study has recorded the breeding of 13
species of raptors from upper Nilgiris (Thirumurthi & Balaji
1999), but the present study recorded only four species. Out of four species recorded, both Brahminy Kite and Black kite have strong fidelity to the
human habitation for nesting and they select the young secondary woods for
nesting. White-rumped
Vulture and Crested Hawk-Eagle preferred live trees of Terminalia
arjuna (primary forest
trees) for nesting along the riparian forest in the valley. Terminalia
arjuna is a hardwood
tree, which provides support to the heavy nests, and their large spreading branches
maximize nest height and reduce nest accessibility to predators. In addition, the riparian forest might reduce
the thermal extremes by facilitating evapotranspiration during incubation and
may be an important factor in nest-tree selection be
these species. All nests of White-rumped Vulture were located in the riverine forest of Sigur Plateau; hence, the protection of riverine habitat is
very crucial for in situ conservation of the southernmost breeding population
of White-rumped Vulture in the subcontinent. Lesser Fish Eagle and Grey-headed Fish-Eagle
are well suited to riverine habitats of the valley and we have sighted a
juvenile of Grey-headed Fish-Eagle. Riparian
forests are complex ecosystems which play a crucial
role in maintaining the water and habitat quality. Even though the riparian forests along many
river systems in the country are devastated, there are still some good
stretches of riverine forest remaining in the Western Ghats that requires the
attention of policy managers (Johnsingh & Joshua
1989). Moyar
River supports unharmed and extensive areas of riparian forest with more than
100 species of woody angiosperms, 120 species of birds, 90 species of fish and
several threatened mammalian fauna having been recorded along the riparian forests
of the river (Bhaskar & Karthik
2015). Construction of hydroelectric
projects, tourism and pollution are considered as the major threat to the
riparian forest of the valley (Bhaskar & Karthik 2015).
Use of pesticide, forest fire, overfishing, spreading
of invasive species and urbanization are prevalent in the landscape and
expected to be a major threat to the survival of the raptorial birds in the
valley. Hence, the present study
suggests to carry out long-term research on raptorial
birds that targets priority information gaps and paying special attention to
the management of the endangered species.
In situ conservation of vultures in Moyar Valley
Even though Gyps vultures have undergone very rapid
population decline across their distribution range, a few breeding populations
have survived in small pockets (Prakash et al. 2003;
MOEF 2006). Nilgiri
Plateau and the surrounding protected area networks spread over the three south
Indian states recorded the existence of five species of vultures: White-rumped Vulture, Red-headed Vulture, Indian Vulture,
Egyptian Vulture and Himalayan Griffon (Gokula
& Vijayan 1996; Ramesh 2011; Venkitachalam
& Senthilnathan 2016; P.A. Vinayan
pers. comm. 2015 December). Moyar River Valley supports one of the largest breeding
populations of White-rumped Vulture in the Western
Ghats, and it is the southernmost breeding range of the species. A major part of the Moyar
valley is not a part of the existing protected area network (National park or
Sanctuary), and hence this study recommends declaring the Moyar
Valley as a “vulture conservation Reserve”.
Also, special attention should be given to the continuous monitoring of
the selected breeding colonies in order to understand their breeding success in
the forested landscape.
Food is a limiting factor for the vultures in Moyar and adjacent forests of Nilgiri
landscape, because vultures mostly depend on the wild ungulate carcass. The Nilgiri-Eastern
Ghats landscape complex supports a good concentration of large carnivores and
their prey in the country (Jhala et al. 2014). The large carnivore kills contribute a
substantial portion of the food consumed by the vultures in the Nilgiri landscape (Ramesh 2011). Hence, the population size of the vultures in
the landscape is directly dependent on the density of prey and predator and
their interactions. Generally, if a
contagious disease is suspected in the death of a large herbivore, the carcass
will be subjected to necropsy and eventually buried or burned. This leads to a reduction of food
availability for vultures. Cattle
depredation by larger carnivores is common in this area, and sometimes the
cattle owners respond by poisoning a carcass (WWF 2010). Vultures are colonial birds, and poisoning
one carcass can potentially lead to the death of several individuals. Measures must be taken to address this
problem.
Vulture breeding colonies are located very close to
human habitations having large cattle populations. Hence, monitoring the prevalence of diclofenac in areas close to vulture habitats is important
to provide a clear understanding of the potential threat to vulture
populations. This study also suggests
exploring the movement ecology of vultures in the study site to understand
their foraging ecology in forested areas and Diclofenac
pressure. Awareness programs need to be
conducted in the valley to increase the knowledge about the importance of
raptors and ensure community participation in the conservation activities.

Table 1. List of the variables measured
for nest-trees and description of quantification method.
|
|
Parameter |
Quantification method |
|
1 |
Altitude |
GPS |
|
2 |
Tree species |
|
|
3 |
Height of the nest tree |
Ocular estimation |
|
4 |
GBH |
Handled measuring tape |
|
5 |
Number of primary branches |
Ocular estimation |
|
6 |
Height of the first primary branch |
Ocular estimation |
|
7 |
Pacing distance |
Measuring tape |
|
8 |
Height of the nest above ground |
Ocular estimation |
|
9 |
Number of branches on which nest was
built |
Ocular estimation |
|
10 |
Distance to the closest nesting tree |
Measuring tape |
|
11 |
Distance to the nearest water body |
Ocular estimation/GIS |
|
12 |
Distance to the nearest human habitation |
GIS |
Table 2. List of diurnal raptors
recorded during the study, their resident, IUCN, and abundance status (December
2012 to March 2013).
|
|
Family/Common name |
Binomial name |
Migrant/resident (India) |
IUCN |
Abundance |
|
|
Accipitridae |
|
|
|
|
|
1 |
Black Eagle |
Ictinaetus malayensis |
BR |
LC |
R |
|
2 |
Black Kite |
Milvus migrans |
BR |
LC |
C |
|
3 |
Black-winged Kite |
Elanus caeruleus |
BR |
LC |
UC |
|
4 |
Bonellis Eagle |
Aquila fasciata
|
BR |
LC |
FC |
|
5 |
Booted Eagle |
Hieraaetus pennatus |
W |
LC |
FC |
|
6 |
Brahminy Kite |
Haliastur indus |
BR |
LC |
C |
|
7 |
Changeable Hawk Eagle (Crested
Hawk-Eagle) |
Nisaetus cirrhatus |
BR |
LC |
FC |
|
8 |
Crested Goshawk |
Accipiter trivirgatus |
BR |
LC |
R |
|
9 |
Crested Serpent-Eagle |
Spilornis cheela |
BR |
LC |
UC |
|
10 |
Eurasian Sparrowhawk |
Accipiter nisus |
W |
LC |
R |
|
11 |
Greater Spotted Eagle |
Clanga clanga |
W |
VU |
R |
|
12 |
Grey-headed Fish-Eagle |
Icthyophaga ichthyaetus |
BR |
NT |
R |
|
13 |
Indian Spotted Eagle |
Clanga hastata |
BR |
VU |
R |
|
14 |
Indian Vulture |
Gyps indicus |
BR |
CR |
UC |
|
15 |
Lesser Fish Eagle |
Icthyophaga humilis |
BR |
NT |
UC |
|
16 |
Oriental Honey-buzzard |
Pernis ptilorhyncus |
BR |
LC |
FC |
|
17 |
Red-headed Vulture |
Sarcogyps calvus |
BR |
CR |
UC |
|
18 |
Rufous-bellied Eagle |
Lophotriorchis kienerii |
BR |
LC |
R |
|
19 |
Shikra |
Accipiter badius |
BR |
LC |
UC |
|
20 |
Short-toed Snake Eagle (Short-toad
eagle) |
Circaetus gallicus |
BR |
LC |
FC |
|
21 |
Steppe Eagle |
Aquila nipalensis |
W |
EN |
R |
|
22 |
Western Marsh-Harrier (Eurasian
Marsh-Harrier) |
Circus aeruginosus |
W |
LC |
R |
|
23 |
White-eyed Buzzard |
Butastar teesa |
BR |
LC |
R |
|
24 |
White-rumped
Vulture |
Gyps bengalensis |
BR |
CR |
C |
|
25 |
Tawny Eagle |
Aquila rapax |
W |
LC |
R |
|
|
Pandionidae |
|
|
|
|
|
26 |
Osprey |
Pandion haliaetus |
W |
LC |
R |
|
|
Falconidae |
|
|
|
|
|
27 |
Common Kestrel |
Falco tinnunculus |
BR |
LC |
UC |
|
28 |
Shaheen Falcon |
Falco peregrinus
peregrinator |
BR |
LC |
R |
Status: BR - Breeding Resident, W - Winter Migrant, LC
- Least Concern, NT - Near Threatened, VU - Vulnerable, EN - Endangered, CR -
Critically Endangered, Abundance: C - Common (≥20 sightings), FC - Fairy Common
(10–20 sightings), U - Uncommon (5–10 sightings), R - Rare (<5 sightings)
Table 3. Variations (Range) in the
nest-tree characteristics among four species of raptors recorded during the
study.
|
Nest-site variables |
Range (min-max) |
|||
|
Crested Hawk-Eagle (n=4) |
White-rumped
Vulture (n=42) |
Black Kite (n=3) |
Brahminy Kite (n=4) |
|
|
Altitude |
376–929 |
817–864 |
907–955 |
960–961 |
|
Height of the nest-tree (m) |
20–37 |
25–53 |
16–19 |
17–30 |
|
GBH (m) |
0.59–1.6 |
1.1–2.70 |
0.7–2 |
0.35–0.60 |
|
Number of primary branches |
4–7 |
3–14 |
3–4 |
6 |
|
Height of the primary branch (m) |
2.5–19 |
3–21 |
4–6 |
5 |
|
Pacing distance (m) |
7–13 |
7.5–20 |
6–10.5 |
6–7 |
|
Height of the nest (m) |
19–35 |
18–52 |
15–18 |
16–29 |
|
Number of branches on which nest was
build |
3 |
2–4 |
2–3 |
2–3 |
|
The distance between closest nest in the
same tree (m) |
- |
3–15 |
- |
- |
|
Distance to the closest nesting tree (m) |
- |
12–1000 |
- |
- |
|
Distance to the nearest water body (m) |
2–15 |
2–10 |
20–50 |
1000–1500 |
|
Distance to human habitation (m) |
50–500 |
700–2000 |
0–50 |
0 |


REFERENCES
Ali, A.M.S., Shanthakumar,
S.B., Kumar,
S.R., Chandran, R., S.S. Marimuthu
& P.R. Arun (2013). Birds of the Sálim Ali
Centre for Ornithology and Natural History Campus, Anaikatty
Hills, southern India. Journal of Threatened Taxa 5: 5288–5298; https://doi.org/10.11609/JoTT.3660.5288-98
Anderson, D.L. (2001). Landscape heterogeneity and diurnal
raptor diversity in Honduras: The Role of indigenous shifting cultivation. Biotropica 33:
511–519.
Arulagam (2015). Recovery Plan for Vultures in Tamil Nadu. Coimbatore, India, 25pp.
Babu, S. & S. Bhupathy (2013). Birds of Meghamalai
Landscape, Southern Western Ghats, India. Journal of Threatened Taxa 5(15): 4962-4972; https://doi.org/10.11609/JoTT.o3594.4962-72
Bhaskar, A. & M. Karthik (2015). Riparian forest for healthy rivers. Current Science 108:
1788–1789.
Bildstein, K.L., W. Schelsky & J.
Zalles
(1998). Conservation status of tropical raptors.
Journal of Raptor Research 32: 3–18.
BirdLife
International (2017). Handbook of the Birds of the World and BirdLife
International digital checklist of the birds of the world. Version 9.1;
http://datazone.birdlife.org/species/taxonomy
Bundell, K. (2010).
Birds of Sirumalai, Tamil Nadu: 1980–2009. Indian
Birds 5: 143–145.
Champion, H.G. & S.K. Seth (1968). Revised Survey of Forest Types in India. Manager
of Publication, New Delhi, 404pp.
Crocker-Bedford,
D.C.
(1990). Goshawk reproduction and forest management.
Wildlife Society Bulletin 18: 262–269.
Eduardo, C., A. Carvalho
& M.A. Marini (2007). Distribution
patterns of diurnal raptors in open and forest habitats in south-eastern
Brazil and the effects of urbanization. Bird Conservation International
17:
367–380.
Ferguson-lees, J.
& D.A. Christie (2005).
Raptors of the World. Christopher
Helm Publisher, London, 992pp.
Gokula, V. & L. Vijayan (1996). Birds of Mudumalai Wildlife
Sanctuary, India. Forktail
12: 143-152.
Grimmett, R., C. Inskipp & T. Inskipp (2011). Birds of the Indian Subcontinent.
Oxford University Press, 528pp.
Henty, C.J. (1977). Thermal soaring of raptors. British Birds 70: 471–475.
Jha, C.S., C.B.S. Dutt &
K.S. Bawa (2000). Deforestation and land use changes in Western Ghats
India. Current Science 79: 231–238.
Jhala, Y.V., Q. Qureshi & R. Gopal (2014).
The Status of Tigers in India. National
Tiger Conservation Authority, The Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun, 19pp.
Johnsingh, A.J.T. (2001). The Kalakad-Mundanthurai
Tiger Reserve: A global heritage of biological diversity. Current
Science 80: 378–388.
Johnsingh, A.J.T. & J. Joshua (1989). The threatened gallery forest of
the River Thamirabarani, Mundanthurai
Wildlife Sanctuary, south India. Biological
Conservation 47: 273–280.
Keith, L.B., S.
Wendy & J. Zalles (1998). Conservation status of tropical
raptors. Journal of Raptor Research 52: 3–18.
Kurup, D.N. (2011). Studies on the Status and
Distribution of Raptors in Wayanad District, Kerala.
Kerala Forest and Wildlife Department, Thiruvananthapuram,
69pp.
MoEF (2006). Action Plan for Vulture
Conservation in India. Ministry of Environment and
Forests, Government of India, New Delhi, 28pp.
Myers, N., Mittermeier, R.A., Mittermeier,
C.G., G. A.B. da Fonseca & J. Kent (2000). Biodiversity hotspots for
conservation priorities. Nature 403: 853–858.
Nair,
S.C. (1991). The Southern Western Ghats
- A Biodiversity Conservation Plan. Indian
National Trust for Art & Cultural Heritage INTACH, New Delhi, 88pp.
Naoroji, R.
(2006). Birds of Prey of the Indian
Sub-continent. Om Books International, Uttar
Pradesh, 690pp.
Newton,
I. (1979). Population Ecology of Raptors.
Buteo
Books, Poyser Ltd., England, 399pp.
Nijman,
V.
(2004). Survey on birds of prey and
owls (falconiformes and Strigiformes)
on Bawean, Java Sea, with records of three species
new to the island. The Raffles Bulletin of Zoology 52:
647–651.
Paine,
R.T. (1966). Food web complexity and
species diversity. The American Naturalist 100:
65–75.
Pearlstine,
E.V., F.J. Mazzotti & M.H. Kelly (2006). Relative distribution and abundance of wintering raptors in agricultural
and wetland landscapes of South Florida. Journal
of Raptor Research 40: 81–85.
Prabhakar,
R. & J.P. Pascal (1994). Nilgiri
Biosphere Reserve Area- vegetation and land use
map. The French Institute of Pondicherry, Pondicherry.
Prakash, V.,
D.J. Pain, A.A. Cunningham, P.F. Donald, N. Prakash,
A. Verma, R. Gargi, S. Sivakumar & A.R Rahmani
(2003). Catastrophic collapse of Indian
White-backed Vulture Gyps bengalensis and
Long-billed Vulture Gyps indicus vulture
populations. Biological Conservation 109: 381–390.
Primrose, A.M. (1904). Birds
observed in the Nilgiris and Wayanaad.
Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society 16:
163–166.
Ramarao, D.,
D. Karuthedathu, K. Mohanram,
H.L. Prakash, A.K. Raju, H.
Sreekumar, S. Kumar & V. Das (2011). On the
breeding of Lesser Fish-Eagle Ichthyophaga humilis in Cauvery Wildlife Sanctuary, Karnataka. Indian Birds 7:
9–13.
Ramesh, T., K. Sankar
& Q. Qureshi (2011). Status of vultures in Mudumalai Tiger
Reserve, Western Ghats, India. Forktail 27: 96–97.
Ramesh,
T., J.P.P. Chakravarthi, S. Balachandran
& R. Kalle (2012). Birds
of lower Palni Hills, Western Ghats, Tamil Nadu. Journal
of Threatened Taxa 4(14): 3269–3283; https://doi.org/10.11609/JoTT.o3051.3269-83
Redpath, S.M. & S.J. Thirgood
(1999). Numerical and functional
responses in generalist predators: Hen harriers and peregrines on Scottish
grouse moors. Journal of Animal Ecology 68: 879–892.
Robinson, S.K. (1994). Habitat selection and foraging
ecology of raptors in Amazonian Peru. Biotropica 26: 443–458.
Roth, T. & D.
Weber (2008). Top predators as indicators for species richness? Prey
species are just as useful. Journal of Applied Ecology 45:
987–991; https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2664.2007.01435.x
Santhakumar, B.,
A.M.S. Ali & P.R. Arun (2016). Status of Greater Spotted Eagle Clanga
clanga in Tamil Nadu and Puducherry,
India. Indian Birds 11: 71–74.
Sashikumar, C.
(2004). Greater Spotted Eagle Aguila
clanga Pallas and Northern Shoveller
Anas clypeata
Linn. Two rare records from Kerala. Journal
of the Bombay Natural History Society 101: 154.
Sashikumar, C.,
J. Praveen, M.J. Palot & P.O. Nameer
(2011). Birds of Kerala: Status and Distributon.
DC
Books. Kotayam, Kerala, 835pp.
Sashikumar, S., C.K. Vishnudas, S. Raju, P.A. Vinayan & S. Kannan (2011). On the status of Lesser Fish-eagle Icthyophaga humilis
in Southern Kerala. Indian Birds 7: 7–9.
Sergio, F., I. Newton, L. Marchesi
& P. Pedrini (2006). Ecologically
justified charisma: preservation of top predators delivers biodiversity
conservation. Journal of Applied Ecology 43: 1049–1055; https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2664.2006.01218.x
Swami, V.N. (2006). Birds of Sirumalai,
Tamil Nadu. Indian Birds 2: 16–17.
Thiollay, J.M.
(1989). Censusing of diurnal raptors in a
primary rain forest: comparative methods and species detectability. Journal of Raptor Research 23: 72–84.
Thiollay, J.M.
(1992). A world review of tropical forest
raptors. Current trends, research objectives and
conservation strategy. Raptor conservation today.
World Working Group on Birds of Prey, Berlin, Germany.
Thiollay, J.M.
(2006). The decline of Raptors in West Africa: Long term assessment
and the role of protected areas. Ibis 148: 240–254; https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1474-919X.2006.00531.x
Thirumurthi, S. & S. Balaji (1999).
Raptors of Nilgiris - a preliminary survey. Newsletter for Birdwatchers 39: 8–10.
van Balan,
S. (1998). Tropical forest raptors in Indonasia:
recent information on distribution, status and conservation. Journal
of Raptor Research 32: 56–63.
Venkitachalam,
R. & S. Senthilnathan (2016). Status and population of vultures in Moyar
Valley, Southern India. Journal of Threatened Taxa 8:
8358-8364; http://dx.doi.org/10.11609/jott.2522.8.1.8358-8364
Vijayan, L.,
T. Sundaramoorthy, C. Sivasubramanian
& J.C. Daniel (1992). Ecology and Behavior of
Resident Raptors with Special Reference to Endangered Species. Sálim Ali Centre
for Ornithology and Natural History (SACON), Coimbatore, India, 36pp.
WGEEP (2011). Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel Report. Ministry of Environment and Forests. Government
of India, New Delhi, 327pp.
WWF (2010). Moyar Valley: Conservation status report. WWF India &
Tamil Nadu Forest Department, Chennai,
India 50pp.
Zarri, A.A., A.R. Rahmani & B. Senthilmurugan
(2008). Birds of the upper Nilgiris
Plateau, Western Ghats, India. Journal of the
Bombay Natural History Society 105: 181–185.